Lawmakers Demand Resignation of Secret Service Director
In the wake of the assassination attempt on Donald Trump, both Democratic and Republican lawmakers have intensified their calls for the resignation of Secret Service Director Kimberly Cheatle. The outcry followed a tense House Oversight Committee hearing on Monday, where Ms. Cheatle was questioned about her agency's security preparations ahead of a 13 July rally in Butler, Pennsylvania, which culminated in the attack on Trump’s life.
The shooting resulted in one fatality and three injuries, including the former president. The hearing, lasting nearly six hours, exposed a rare bipartisan consensus on Capitol Hill, with lawmakers from both sides expressing severe dissatisfaction with the agency's handling of the situation.
During the hearing, lawmakers probed how suspect Thomas Matthew Crooks managed to access a nearby rooftop and why Trump was allowed to take the stage despite reports of a suspicious individual. The session was marked by sharp criticism of Ms. Cheatle’s responses and the agency’s limited public disclosure of information.
Following the hearing, committee leaders James Comer and Jamie Raskin sent a letter to Ms. Cheatle, outlining their belief that she should step down. “In the middle of a presidential election, the Committee and the American people demand serious institutional accountability and transparency that you are not providing,” the letter stated. “We call on you to resign as Director as a first step to allowing new leadership to swiftly address this crisis and rebuild the trust of a truly concerned Congress and the American people.”
While Ms. Cheatle took responsibility for the security lapses and acknowledged that the Butler incident represented "the most significant operational failure of the Secret Service in decades," her responses did little to quell lawmakers' frustrations. She resisted calls to resign, asserting that she remains "the best person to lead the Secret Service at this time."
Throughout the hearing, Ms. Cheatle's reluctance to answer direct questions, citing the ongoing investigation, further inflamed tensions. Oversight Committee Chairman James Comer criticized her lack of transparency, stating, “The American people have questions, and they deserve answers. You were required to provide answers, and, ma’am, you did not.”
The hearing often descended into chaos, with lawmakers using expletives, shouting at Ms. Cheatle, and questioning her honesty and competence. “I’m disgusted by your performance,” remarked Florida Congresswoman Anna Paulina Luna. Ms. Cheatle's responses frequently provoked irritation, with some lawmakers suggesting her dismissal if she continued to refuse to resign.
Ohio Republican Jim Jordan, a Trump ally, accused Ms. Cheatle of evading basic questions and cutting corners in protecting one of the world’s most prominent individuals. South Carolina Republican Nancy Mace expressed her frustration by using expletives in response to Ms. Cheatle’s answers about leaked remarks, while Georgia’s Marjorie Taylor Greene denounced Ms. Cheatle as a “total failure,” adding, “The entire country is demanding you resign.”
Ms. Cheatle also revealed that no Secret Service officers or employees have been disciplined for the Butler incident. She indicated that a preliminary report on the shooting would be released within 60 days, a timeline that committee members deemed unacceptable.
New York’s Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez criticized the delay, emphasizing the urgency of addressing the safety of highly targeted individuals. “This is not theatre, this is not about jockeying; this is about the safety of some of the most highly targeted and valued targets internationally and domestically,” she said. “We need answers and policy decisions. Without that, we’re flying blind.”
Despite the general agreement on Ms. Cheatle’s future, disagreements emerged between Republicans and Democrats on the committee. Some Republicans criticized Ms. Cheatle as a "DEI" hire and questioned the capability of female agents assigned to Trump’s security detail. Others, such as Colorado’s Lauren Boebert and Ms. Luna, alluded to conspiracy theories circulating online. Florida Republican Michael Waltz blamed Ms. Cheatle for fueling misinformation, asserting that her lack of prompt communication was a critical misstep.
Eyewitnesses to the shooting expressed frustration with Ms. Cheatle’s performance. Jean Vincent, a Butler resident, criticized her responses as inadequate, stating, “She needs to be held accountable for her total lack of competency… she put our lives at risk and needs to take responsibility.” Former US Marine Teresa Wilson echoed this sentiment, suggesting that Ms. Cheatle’s evasiveness was unacceptable and that resignation was the only suitable course of action.