Normandy Train Derailment: SNCF Defends Employees as Investigation Raises Safety Concerns
France's national railway operator, SNCF, has defended its employees following a regional train derailment in Normandy, as preliminary investigation findings raise questions about emergency communication procedures and the risk of a potentially more serious accident.
The incident occurred on September 13, 2026, when a regional TER train travelling between Rouen and Caen derailed near Cléon, in the Seine-Maritime department. The accident left 44 people injured, including one seriously.
In a statement released on November 21, SNCF Voyageurs rejected suggestions that its employees had exposed passengers to additional danger, emphasizing that the train's conductor and onboard supervisor acted promptly despite significant communication difficulties.
Emergency Response Under Difficult Conditions
According to SNCF Voyageurs, the onboard supervisor immediately alerted emergency services using a professional telephone after the train left the tracks.
The driver, whose locomotive had overturned during the accident, was unable to use the usual railway communication equipment. The onboard radio had stopped working, while the impact had also rendered his work phone unavailable.
After managing to leave the damaged driver's cabin, he used his personal mobile phone to raise the alarm.
SNCF maintains that these actions played a decisive role in securing the railway section and stopping traffic before another train travelling in the opposite direction could reach the accident area.
The company praised both employees for their professionalism, arguing that the available evidence does not establish any failure in their response.
Investigation Identifies a Communication Gap
The defence comes after the French Land Transport Accident Investigation Bureau (BEA-TT) published an initial assessment highlighting a departure from established emergency procedures.
Investigators found that neither the driver nor the onboard supervisor directly notified SNCF Réseau's traffic management service, known as the Service de Gestion des Circulations (SGC).
Under standard railway safety protocols, this notification is a critical step following a derailment, as it allows railway controllers to immediately suspend train movements across the affected section.
Although the driver was physically unable to make the required contact, the onboard supervisor instead alerted another coordination structure, the operational production centre.
The BEA-TT acknowledged that the employee also focused on assisting injured passengers and helping travellers leave the damaged train.
However, the investigation revealed that some passengers ended up on the opposite railway track, where another train was approaching.
A Potentially More Serious Accident Narrowly Avoided
One of the most concerning findings involves the proximity of the second train to the area where passengers had evacuated.
According to the BEA-TT, the approaching service was stopped approximately two kilometres from the danger zone following an instruction from a railway traffic controller.
Investigators have not yet explained precisely what information prompted the controller to order the train to stop.
The agency suggested that a combination of circumstances may have prevented a second accident involving passengers on the tracks and the approaching train.
It has therefore issued an interim recommendation to SNCF Voyageurs, highlighting the need to reinforce emergency communication procedures and ensure that the appropriate railway control services are notified immediately after an accident.
SNCF Challenges the Investigation's Assessment
SNCF Voyageurs expressed reservations about the investigation's suggestion that the absence of a more serious accident may have resulted partly from favourable circumstances.
The company argued that this assessment overlooks the importance of the immediate alerts issued by its employees and the subsequent interruption of railway traffic.
While defending its staff, the operator confirmed that it was examining the BEA-TT's recommendation as part of the ongoing investigation.
The September derailment is also the subject of a separate judicial investigation seeking to establish its precise causes. Authorities have previously examined the possibility of deliberate interference with railway infrastructure.
The technical investigation has not yet delivered its final conclusions.
The case has brought renewed attention to railway emergency procedures in France, particularly the coordination between onboard personnel, operational centres and traffic controllers when communication systems fail during a major incident.
-
10:15
-
10:00
-
09:45
-
09:30
-
09:15
-
09:00
-
08:45
-
01:00
-
00:15
-
23:00
-
22:30
-
22:00
-
21:30
-
21:00
-
20:30
-
20:00
-
19:00
-
18:30
-
18:00
-
17:30
-
17:00
-
16:30
-
16:00
-
15:30
-
15:00
-
14:58
-
14:39
-
14:32
-
14:30
-
14:25
-
14:21
-
14:15
-
14:10
-
14:03
-
14:00
-
13:56
-
13:55
-
13:30
-
13:00
-
12:45
-
12:30
-
12:15
-
12:00
-
11:45
-
11:30
-
11:18
-
11:15
-
11:00
-
10:45
-
10:30