Utah high court halts firing squad execution of man with Dementia
The Utah Supreme Court on Friday temporarily blocked the execution of Ralph Leroy Menzies, a 67-year-old man convicted of killing Maurine Hunsaker in 1986, after his attorneys argued that he suffers from severe dementia. Menzies had been scheduled to face a firing squad on September 5, a method he chose decades ago, which would have made him the sixth U.S. prisoner executed by firing squad since 1977.
His lawyers argued that Menzies’ dementia, developed during his 37 years on death row, has left him reliant on a wheelchair and oxygen, and unable to understand why he is facing execution. The Supreme Court acknowledged that his case raises a significant question regarding his competency and ordered a lower court to re-evaluate whether he is fit to be executed.
“This uncertainty has caused the Hunsaker family immense suffering, and it is not our desire to prolong that suffering,” the court stated, emphasizing that the law must guide its decisions. Defense attorneys stressed that Menzies’ cognitive condition has worsened since his last evaluation.
Past U.S. Supreme Court rulings have barred executions for individuals with severe mental illness, citing constitutional protections against cruel and unusual punishment. Medical experts continue to debate Menzies’ mental capacity, with prosecutors asserting he understands his situation and defense experts disagreeing.
-
17:50
-
17:20
-
17:00
-
17:00
-
16:40
-
16:20
-
16:00
-
15:40
-
15:20
-
14:50
-
14:20
-
13:50
-
13:20
-
12:50
-
12:45
-
12:30
-
12:20
-
12:15
-
12:00
-
11:50
-
11:45
-
11:30
-
11:20
-
11:00
-
10:50
-
10:30
-
10:20
-
10:00
-
10:00
-
09:50
-
09:30
-
09:20
-
09:00
-
08:50
-
08:30
-
08:20
-
08:00
-
07:50
-
07:40
-
07:20
-
07:00
